Jun 052012
 

The Lie-Nielsen #1 and #2 are the smallest of the bench planes, with the lower number being smaller in size. As bench planes, the iron rests on a frog (45 degrees in these two sizes) and is used in a bevel down configuration. The #1 is only offered in Bronze, which is heavier than the same plane would be in Iron, and has the added benefit that the body will not rust. One difference in the #1, compared to the rest of the line of Lie-Nielsen bench planes, is the fact that the body is not modeled along the Stanley Bedrock design. The #2 does follow the Bedrock design, and is offered both in Iron and Bronze. Both the #1 and #2 planes come with the A2 iron, and are set up like other bench planes.

With the size of the #1, many ask how they should hold it, since it is very compact. While I don’t have the largest of hands, I still tend to hold it a bit differently than most other bench planes. I’ll cup my rear hand around the handle, with my hand in sort of a U shape, and grip it similarly to a block plane. My front hand holds the knob, as you would expect, and makes for a more comfortable long term grip for me compared to the same time with a block plane. Now that I have this way of working with it, there are times I’ll grab my #1 instead of one of my block planes.

The #2, while small, is a fair amount larger than the #1. The #2’s size is such that some will feel comfortable using the grip I described for the #1 above, while others will hold it with a standard (although a bit more cramped) grip. I accomplish my standard grip by holding the handle with my lower three fingers, and pointing my index finger forward, very much like holding a saw. Since the #2 is available in both Iron and Bronze, I tend to get questions about which one is best. For some, the reduced rust aspect can be critical, depending on where they live, but the extra mass in the Bronze can be seen as a positive as well. In my opinion, both the Iron and Bronze work the same when taking shavings. It really comes down to personal preference, unless it is a gift for a small child, where the extra weight could possibly be an issue. Even if you choose the Bronze body, remember you should still apply some rust preventative on the blade, like Jojoba Oil or Camellia Oil. The Iron bodied version would require this, as well as to the body, as it’s always better to prevent rust than to try to eradicate it after the fact. There are also silicone-treated sacks available for storage.

A question I get quite often is why someone would use these smallest bench planes. Even though I recognize the smallest Lie-Nielsen planes are very cute, they all work just as well as their larger brothers (or sisters). I find the scale of work helps me decide which size bench plane to choose for a given project. For instance, I find it easier to use a smallish plane when cleaning up the edges of 1/4” thick boards I use for the sides of some of my dovetailed boxes, rather than trying to balance my #8 jointer on the very thin edges. Another good reason to have a smaller (and shorter) bench plane in your arsenal is when you need to work a small area of a board that doesn’t need to be dead flat, but you still want to finish it with a plane. As you likely know, the longer the plane bed, the more flat is required to take a full length shaving, since the bed rides on top of any crests that might exist. The iron takes material off of the top of the crest, but can’t reach down into the valley. With a shorter plane, and depending on how far apart any crests might be, you can work down into the valley without the need to completely flatten the board first. This way you will still have a planed surface, instead of scraping or moving to sandpaper.

I find the #1 and #2 are both extremely functional and quite flexible. Either would be a nice addition to your kit.

Now go make some shavings! Let me know if you have any questions or suggestions for future articles.


Click the links to take a closer look at the Lie Nielsen #1 bench plane , #2 bronze bench plane and #2 cast ductile iron bench plane.

To see Highland Woodworking’s entire selection of Lie-Nielsen hand tools, click here.


Lee Laird has enjoyed woodworking for over 20 years. He is retired from the U.S.P.S. and works for Lie-Nielsen Toolworks as a show staff member, demonstrating tools and training customers.

Print Friendly

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>